Basal cell carcinoma vs squamous cell carcinoma eyelid

Eyelid malignancies account for approximately 10% of all skin cancers.  Although they are seldom fatal,  they can lead to significant tissue damage and may spread to other orbital and facial structures.  Eyelid cancers are most prevalent in light-skinned individuals who have experienced significant sun exposure over time, and they also occur most frequently on the lower eyelid.  Basal cell carcinomas account for approximately 90% of all eyelid cancer cases, Squamous cell carcinomas occur approximately 5% of the time and melanoma, one of the most dangerous forms, accounts for approximately 1-2% of cases.  Other rare carcinomas such as sebaceous cell and Merkel cell are also possible in the eye area.

Basal cell carcinoma (BCC) develops in the basal cells within the epidermis (top layer) of the skin. Basal cell carcinoma is the most common type of skin cancer of the eyelids and accounts for approximately 90% of all eyelid cancer cases.  The most prevalent cause of basal cell carcinoma is prolonged exposure to UV rays of the sun.  They usually develop as small, firm, painless nodules with a smooth, pearly appearance.  They may also develop telangiectasia (a reddish color as a result of dilated capillaries).

Basal cell carcinomas rarely metastasize to lymph nodes or distant organs, but they are still considered malignant.  If they are not detected and treated early, then they can cause local destruction of surrounding tissues including the eye, the orbital cavity and the nasal cavity.  Basal cell carcinomas are often treated by removing the tumor via Mohs micrographic surgery.  Based on the size of the excision, scars are minimized via reconstruction of the affected area.

Squamous cell carcinoma is a more aggressive form of skin cancer that develops in the squamous cells of the epidermis (top layer of the skin).  Squamous cell carcinomas occur most frequently in areas that are subjected to prolonged exposure to the sun's harmful UV rays.  In the eye area, squamous cell carcinomas usually occur on the eyelids and look like raised, scaly patches of reddened skin that may resemble a scab that does not heal.  They are more dangerous than basal cell carcinomas in that they can metastasize to lymph nodes and distant organs, so early detection and treatment is important.  If a squamous cell carcinoma develops, then removal of the tumor and the surrounding tissues via Mohs micrographic surgery is the primary treatment.

Melanoma is a more serious type of skin cancer because it often metastasizes to lymph nodes and distant organs versus other types of skin cancer.  Melanoma begins in melanocytes, the cells that produce pigment in the skin, eyes and hair. While melanoma can occur in any area where melanocytes are found, most melanocytes are present in the skin, making it the most common form of the disease.   Early detection of melanoma is important, as the survival rate is very high if detected before it spreads to other organs.  Once detected, a team of doctors will work with you to determine the best course of treatment.  For more information, go to www.melanoma.org.

Sebaceous cell carcinoma is a rare form of cancer of the eyelids often mistaken for benign conditions such as a sty or chalazion (a small bump on the eyelid caused by a blockage of an oil gland), as the tumors originate from the glands in the eyelid that produce the oily layer of tears. Any "sty" or chalazion that does not resolve within several weeks to months must be evaluated to rule out a possible sebaceous cell carcinoma. The treatment consists of surgical removal and monitoring to ensure distant metastasis does not occur.

 Merkel cell carcinoma or MCC is a rare but aggressive skin cancer that arises from the uncontrolled growth of Merkel cells in the skin. . MCC has the potential to be lethal, and thus prompt, aggressive treatment is important. For more information, go to www.merkelcell.org.

As an ophthalmologist and oculoplastic surgeon, Dr, Elahi specializes in detecting and treating cancers surrounding the eye area.  He also works closely with a team of highly regarded dermatologic surgeons, oncologists and other surgeons when more aggressive treatments are indicated.

Make an Appointment

Our team is here to help you make an appointment with the specialists that you need.

About Eyelid Tumors

Eyelid skin is the most sensitive and the thinnest and can be easily damaged by the sun’s ultraviolet rays and is the most common region for skin cancers, especially on the lower eyelids. Most eyelid tumors are basal cell carcinomas, a slow-growing type of skin cancer that rarely spreads to distant sites in the body. Squamous cell and sebaceous gland carcinomas and malignant melanoma are also found on the eyelid and are more aggressive than basal cell carcinoma and can spread to nearby lymph nodes and other parts of the body.

Symptoms

Symptoms of skin cancers that develop on the eyelid include:

  • A smooth, shiny, or pearly bump or one this is firm and red.
  • A sore or lump that bleed or develops a crust or a scab that does not heal quickly.
  • A flat, flesh-colored, or brown scar-like lesion or a rough, scaly red or brown patched area.
  • An itchy or tender flat spot with a scaly, crusted surface.
  • A stye that does not heal.
  • Loss of eyelashes.

Diagnosis

Columbia ophthalmologists are specially trained to carefully examine any abnormality on the eyelid to diagnose cancer. They can usually confirm the diagnosis through a surgical biopsy by one of Columbia’s expert pathologists. Additional testing may include imaging such as a CT, computed axial tomography (CAT), or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan. 

Imaging tests, such as computed tomography (CT) or computed axial tomography (CAT) scans, or MRI (magnetic resonance imaging) scans. A sentinel lymph node biopsy is used to examine the sentinel lymph node, the regional node to which cancer may spread, and analyze it for the presence of cancer cells.

Treatments We Offer

Ophthalmologists treat tumors on the eyelid in a variety of safe and effective ways, including:

  • Mohs microsurgery – Our Columbia surgeons remove the tumor and a small margin of skin around it in very thin layers, examining each layer for tumor cells as it is removed, ensuring the best removal of cancer and the least amount of healthy surrounding tissue, and decreasing the rate of recurrence.
  • Frozen section control – Similar to Mohs, the tumor is removed in very thin layers
  • Radiation therapy – Using high-energy x-rays or other types of radiation to kill cancer cells
  • Chemotherapy and targeted therapy – Using topical chemotherapy in the form of eye drops to use after the surgical area has healed
  • Cryotherapy – The localized use of extreme cold produced by liquid nitrogen (or argon gas) to kill the cancer cells

Why Choose Columbia?

Our Columbia ophthalmologists will work tirelessly to give you the best prognosis possible with an excellent cosmetic and functional outcome with early diagnosis and treatment.  

How do I know if I have basal cell or squamous cell carcinoma?

In a biopsy, the doctor takes out a small piece of tissue to check it for cancer cells. A biopsy is the only way to tell for sure if you have skin cancer and what kind it is. There are many types of skin biopsies. Ask your doctor what kind you will need.

What does squamous cell carcinoma look like on the eyelid?

Squamous cell carcinomas, like BCCs, occur most frequently on the lower eyelid. SCCs often appear as painless nodular or plaque-like lesions with irregular rolled edges, chronic scaling with roughened patches, fissuring of the skin, pearly borders, telangiectasia and central ulceration.

Can you get squamous cell carcinoma on your eyelid?

Squamous Cell Carcinoma (SCC) of the eyelid is malignant epidermal carcinoma. SCC is the second most common eyelid malignancy, accounting for less than 5% of malignant eyelid neoplasms. Basal cell carcinoma is up to 40 times more common than SCC.

What does basal cell carcinoma look like on eyelid?

Patients with basal cell carcinomas most commonly notice a reddish nodule slowly forming on their eyelid. The tumor is most commonly found on the lower eyelid, followed by the medial canthus (skin toward the nose) and can occur on the upper eyelid.