Which is better cash out refinance or home equity loan

Insider's experts choose the best products and services to help make smart decisions with your money (here’s how). In some cases, we receive a commission from our our partners, however, our opinions are our own. Terms apply to offers listed on this page.

• Both home equity loans and cash-out refinances allow you to turn home equity into cash.
• A cash-out refinancing replaces your existing mortgage with one that has a larger balance.
• A home equity loan is considered a second mortgage and comes with an additional monthly payment.

Owning a home lets you build up equity that you can turn into cash when you need it, whether for home repairs, your child's college tuition, to pay off debts, or for any other financial needs.

Cash-out refinancing and home equity loans are two of the most popular tools available to do this. But they aren't created equal. Here's what you need to know about each to help decide which is the best choice for your situation.

Cash-out refinancing vs. home equity loan: At a glance

Cash-out refinancing and home equity loans both allow you to access your home equity with a single lump-sum payment. 

The main difference between the two is:

• A cash-out refinance replaces your current mortgage loan with a larger one. You get the difference between the two balances in cash.
• A home equity loan is a new loan on top of your existing mortgage. It comes with an additional monthly payment.

In both cases, there are no restrictions on how you can use the money. Many people use cash-out refinances and home equity loans to pay for home renovations or repairs. Since mortgage loans often carry lower interest rates  than other financial products, some homeowners see cash-out refinancing as a good way to consolidate other debts. 

What is cash-out refinancing?

A cash-out refinance works like this: You apply for a new mortgage loan that's larger than your current one. Once approved, that loan is used to pay off your old one, and you get the difference back in cash at closing. 

Cash-out refinances come with either adjustable or fixed interest rates with terms between 15 and 30 years. Typically, your loan-to-value ratio (LTV) can be as much as 80% of your home's value. There will also be closing costs — usually around $5,000 on average.

The biggest benefit of a cash-out refinance is that it comes with no extra payment. It also typically comes with a lower interest rate than a home equity loan would.

"It's the cheapest way to borrow against the equity in your home," says Melissa Cohn, regional vice president of William Raveis Mortgage.

With a cash-out refinance, your mortgage interest payments are tax deductible. Depending on your rate and loan balance, this could substantially reduce your taxable income.

The downside of cash-out refinancing is that it replaces your current mortgage, which could mean trading a low rate for a higher one. There are also closing costs to consider. If you think you might sell the home soon, those costs may not be worth it.

"If you're going to borrow the money long-term, cash-out refinancing makes sense," Cohn says.

Example of cash-out refinancing

Say your home was worth $500,000, and your current mortgage loan balance was $300,000. 

The cash-out refinancing process would look something like this:

1. You'd apply for a new mortgage loan. Since cash-out refinances typically allow for up to an 80% LTV, that means you could apply for as much as $400,000 in funding ($500,000 x .80). 
2. You'd submit the required financial documentation. Lenders typically require bank statements, pay stubs, tax returns, and W-2s, among other items.
3. Have your home appraised. In most cases, your lender will want to verify your home's value with a new appraisal.
4. You'd close on the loan, and the new loan would be used to pay off the old mortgage balance, leaving you with an overage of $100,000.
5. You'd get that $100,000 in a lump-sum payment within a few days of closing.

What is a home equity loan?

A home equity loan is a type of second mortgage. Unlike cash-out refinancing, it doesn't replace your current mortgage loan. Instead, it's a loan in addition to your original mortgage — meaning you'll have two monthly payments.

Home equity loans typically come with fixed interest rates and terms of anywhere from five to 30 years. These loans also come with closing costs, though they're typically lower than what you'll see on a cash-out refinance. Some lenders will even cover them entirely. In most cases, home equity loans let you access up to 80% of your home value — across both your home equity loan and your primary mortgage. Some lenders may have limits as high as 90% for certain borrowers.

The main drawback of a home equity loan is that it comes with a second monthly payment. Rates can also be higher, and your interest costs may not be tax-deductible. With home equity mortgages, you can only deduct the interest if you use the funds to "buy, build, or substantially improve" your home. And even then, you'd need to itemize your returns to take this deduction.

On the upside, home equity loans let you keep the terms of your original mortgage, which might be good if you're very far into your amortization schedule when more of your payments are going toward your principal balance and not toward interest. It's also smart if interest rates on traditional mortgages are rising, and you don't want to lose the low rate you already have.

"For homeowners whose primary mortgage rate is below the current market rates, a home equity loan is more likely to be the better choice," says Nicole Straub, SVP and head of Discover Home Loans. "By choosing this option, it allows them to keep the low rate they have while also allowing them to tap into the equity they have in their home."

Example of a home equity loan

Say your home's value is $500,000. Since home equity loans typically allow for loan-to-value ratios of 80%, you could access as much as $400,000 across both your main mortgage and a new home equity loan. If your current mortgage balance was $350,000, for example, a home equity loan could presumably offer you up to $50,000 in upfront cash ($400,000 - $350,000). 

To get your home equity loan, you'd file an application with your chosen lender, submit documentation, and have your house appraised. Once you pay your closing costs and sign the paperwork, you'd receive your lump-sum payment a few days later. You'd then begin making monthly payments toward your home equity loan starting the next month.

Putting it all together

Both home equity loans and cash-out refinancing can help you turn equity into cash. But the best choice depends on your unique budget, the terms of your original mortgage, and your long-term plans as a homeowner.

Either way, home equity loans and cash-out refinances will likely save you money compared to other financial products you may be considering.

"Both home equity loans and cash-out refinances are types of secured debt with an average interest rate typically lower than what you'll find with other types of unsecured debt — such as a credit card or personal loans," Straub says.

If you're not sure which product is right for your situation, reach out to a mortgage broker or financial advisor for help. You can also ask lenders for quotes for both products and compare the two options side by side.

Aly J. Yale is a freelance writer, specializing in real estate, mortgage, and the housing market. Her work has been published in Forbes, Money Magazine, Bankrate, The Motley Fool, The Balance, Money Under 30, and more. Prior to freelancing, she served as an editor and reporter for The Dallas Morning News. She graduated from TCU's Bob Schieffer College of Communication with a focus on radio-TV-film and news-editorial journalism. Connect with her on Twitter or LinkedIn.

Read more Read less

What are the disadvantages of a cash

Is home equity same as cash

When should you use a Heloc vs cash

Is the interest rate higher on a cash